Washington AG Too Woke to Defend the Law Voters Just Passed by 12 Points

Washington AG Too Woke to Defend the Law Voters Just Passed by 12 Points

Washington state voters passed Initiative 638 last week by a 12-point margin. The measure prohibits biological boys from competing in school athletic programs intended for female students only. Clear language. Clear mandate.

The state's attorney general won't defend it.

Nick Brown, Washington's attorney general and a staunch supporter of transgender causes, has recused himself from legally defending Initiative 638 in court. Rather than doing the job voters elected him to do — defending duly enacted law — Brown appointed outside counsel to handle the case after transgender activists filed a lawsuit challenging the measure.

Think about what that means in practice. The people of Washington used the ballot initiative process, the most direct form of democracy available, to protect girls' sports. They didn't sneak it through a committee. They didn't attach it to a spending bill at midnight. They put it on the ballot, campaigned for it, and won by 12 points. And the man whose constitutional duty is to defend state law in court decided his personal ideology matters more than the outcome.

Brown didn't even pretend to wrestle with the decision. He didn't claim a procedural conflict or cite some obscure legal technicality. He's a "staunch supporter of transgender causes," as the Washington Examiner reported, and that was apparently enough. The state's top lawyer looked at a law passed by an overwhelming majority of his own constituents and said: I'm not touching that.

The lawsuit from transgender activists was predictable. Every state that moves to protect female athletics gets one. The playbook hasn't changed in years — pass a law, get sued, fight it in court. That's how the system works. What doesn't work is the state's own attorney general volunteering to sit on the bench while someone else does his job.

Outside counsel will now defend Initiative 638 with taxpayer money. Brown still collects his salary. The voters who passed the measure by a comfortable double-digit margin get to watch their elected legal representative hand the case off to a stranger because defending girls' sports was too ideologically inconvenient.

Attorneys general don't get to pick which laws they like. The office exists to represent the state — all of it, including the parts that disagree with the AG's politics. Brown swore an oath to uphold and defend the laws of Washington. Initiative 638 is now one of those laws.

He recused himself anyway.

Every attorney general in the country takes cases they personally disagree with. That's the job description. You defend the law as written, not the law as you wish it were. Brown looked at that job description, looked at Initiative 638's 12-point victory, and decided his transgender advocacy credentials were more important than either one.

The voters of Washington didn't elect an activist. They elected a lawyer. He gave them an activist anyway.


Most Popular

Most Popular