The New York City chapter of the Democratic Socialists of America has an official choir. It's called Sing in Solidarity. It has about 50 members, a music director named Pablo O'Connell, and it was co-founded in 2018 by a woman named Annie Levin. They rehearse at the Abrons Arts Center on the Lower East Side, they break into four-part harmony — sopranos, altos, tenors, basses — and at the NYC-DSA city convention this past weekend, they sang a rewrite of "When the Saints Go Marching In" about a future with no NYPD, free homes, free Palestine, and free healthcare "when the revolution comes."
With sheet music. In organized vocal parts. At an official party convention.
The performance came on the heels of a resolution the convention passed unanimously — 399 to 0 — titled "Build Community Safety through Prevention, Not Policing." The resolution formally calls for abolishing the New York City Police Department and replacing it with a Department of Community Safety. Not reforming. Not reimagining. Replacing.
Twitchy featured the video on November 19th, and the reactions wrote themselves. One commenter called it "indistinguishable from a cult." Hard to argue when you're watching middle-aged socialists in matching arrangements belt out revolutionary fantasies to a folk hymn.
The DSA's national platform states the goal plainly: "demilitarize police departments, disempower police unions, and redirect funding to public services as steps towards fully abolishing the police and prison system." That's not a Twitchy paraphrase. That's their own language, from their own documents.
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani — a dues-paying DSA member himself — has been moving in this direction already. He disbanded the Strategic Response Group, a counter-terrorism unit that had been used for protest policing. He established an Office of Community Safety with roughly $260 million in funding. During his campaign, he promised a $1 billion Department of Community Safety budget. The DSA convention resolution is essentially a demand that he move faster.
The convention also passed a resolution urging Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez — another dues-paying DSA member — to run for president in 2028. Al Jazeera reported on that one. So the same organization singing about the end of policing in New York wants to put one of its members in the White House.
Manhattan Institute polling from July found that 82 percent of Americans oppose police abolition. Eighty-two percent. The DSA voted 399-0 in favor of it. That's not a disconnect between a political organization and its voters. That's an organization that has stopped pretending to care what voters think.
The Columbia News Service profiled Sing in Solidarity and described the choir as "a radicalizing space" where people who showed up to sing ended up becoming socialists. Their repertoire includes "Solidarity Forever," songs from the Industrial Workers of the World's Little Red Songbook, and a Chilean protest song from 1969 with added verses about a Palestinian poet. This isn't a group that wandered into politics by accident.
Three hundred and ninety-nine delegates. Zero dissent. A choir performance to celebrate. And a mayor who's already implementing the platform they're singing about.
The quiet part isn't quiet anymore. It's in four-part harmony.
